- Enhanced graph_routes.py and query_routes.py to support multi-tenant architecture by introducing tenant-specific RAG instances. - Updated create_graph_routes and create_query_routes functions to accept rag_manager for tenant management. - Added get_tenant_rag dependency to all relevant endpoints to ensure tenant context is utilized for operations. - Modified Vite configuration to include comprehensive API proxy rules for seamless interaction with backend services. - Implemented cascade delete functionality in tenant_service.py for tenant and knowledge base deletions. - Added detailed logging and error handling for tenant operations. - Created audit logs documenting the multi-tenant implementation process and decisions made.
1.8 KiB
1.8 KiB
Task Log: Multi-Tenant vs Workspace Audit
Date: 2024-12-05 01:30 UTC
Mode: Beastmode
Task: Audit Multi-Tenant vs Workspace redundancy
Actions
- Fetched upstream LightRAG README to understand workspace feature
- Analyzed core
lightrag/lightrag.pyworkspace parameter usage - Analyzed
lightrag/kg/postgres_impl.pyfor table schemas with workspace - Analyzed
lightrag/services/tenant_service.pyfor tenant management - Analyzed
lightrag/tenant_rag_manager.pyfor RAG instance management - Analyzed
lightrag/models/tenant.pyfor data models - Analyzed
lightrag/security.pyfor workspace/tenant validation - Analyzed
starter/init-postgres.sqlfor database schema - Used sequential thinking to compare architectures
- Created comprehensive audit report:
docs/0009-multi-tenant-vs-workspace-audit.md - Implemented cascade delete for
delete_knowledge_base()method - Implemented cascade delete for
delete_tenant()method - Fixed linting issues with ruff
Decisions
- Tenant feature is NOT redundant - it's a proper application layer on top of workspace
- Workspace provides storage-level isolation (HOW data is separated)
- Tenant provides application-level multi-tenancy (WHO can access WHAT)
- Composite workspace format
{tenant_id}:{kb_id}bridges the two layers
Next Steps
- Add unit tests for cascade delete functionality
- Consider adding DB triggers for referential integrity
- Update user-facing documentation with workspace naming convention
Lessons/Insights
- LightRAG uses a layered architecture that correctly separates storage isolation from access control
- Generated columns in PostgreSQL allow querying by tenant/KB without schema changes
- The
TenantRAGManageracts as a bridge, creating composite workspace identifiers